New and noteworthy verdicts and settlements from around the country, selected by VerdictSearch editors. Find out about the case most relevant to your practice, with complete details on awards and settlements; injuries claimed; experts, attorneys, insurers and judges involved; and more.
Click on a state to view the latest featured verdicts by state:
New York Verdicts
Find out about the most important recent New York cases, selected by VerdictSearch editors. Coverage includes Bronx, Kings, Queens, New York, Nassau, Suffolk and Westchester counties.
Doctor defeats claim of improper infection control
An oral surgeon prevailed in a lawsuit filed by a patient who alleged that an infection was not properly addressed. The matter dates to March 2013, when Daniel Alvarado underwent extraction of an infected tooth. Alvarado’s infection subsequently spread to his trachea and necessitated further surgery. He fully recovered, but he later sued, alleging that the tooth extraction should have been delayed until his infection had resolved. He claimed that he endured unnecessary pain, suffering and surgery as a result of the infection’s spread. A jury sided with the defense, which argued that the extraction was immediately necessary and that Alvarado’s infection spread because he neglected to utilize an antibiotic that had been recommended.
Alvarado v. Manhattan Oral Facial Surgery, LLC
New York County
Jury awards $1 million in school bullying case
A jury determined that a New York school district must pay $940,000 to a former student who endured years of bullying. The suit’s plaintiff, Anthony Motta, now 20, claimed that he was bullied throughout his four years at Eldred Junior-Senior High School, in Eldred. He claimed that bullies physically attacked him, destroyed his personal property and continually mocked him, but that the school’s staff did little beyond some failed attempts at mediation. The defense contended that Motta was just as much an aggressor in the bullying and that it properly addressed the bullying, but the jury found otherwise. It awarded $1 million, which included a total of $60,000 for a derivative claim by Motta’s parents.
Motta v. Eldred Central School District
No damages for man disappointed with surgery’s result
A jury rejected a man who sued for damages after plastic surgery left his nose scarred. The lawsuit was filed by Brian McBride, who was unhappy with the aesthetic result of a septorhinoplasty that was performed in 2012. The procedure involved reshaping of his septum and the interior of his nose, but the surgeon inadvertently inflicted a laceration that left a scar on the left side of the nose. The dispute proceeded to trial, where the parties’ medical experts debated whether a laceration of the exterior of the nose constitutes a departure from accepted medical care. The jury believed the defense’s contention that the laceration was a rare but medically accepted occurrence.
McBride v. Pearlman
New York County
|$75,000,000||Robaey v. Air & Liquid Systems Corp.||New York Co.||Jan 20|
|$71,000,000||Wang v. Sexton||New York Co.||Sep 28|
|$41,500,000||Frosch v. City of New York||Queens Co.||Oct 24|
|$37,397,513||Klupchak v. First East Village Associates||New York Co.||Mar 7|
|$33,500,000||Doomes v. Best Transit Corp.||Bronx Co.||Feb 7|
|$26,190,000||Buck v. Llopiz-Valle||Kings Co.||Oct 31|
|$20,000,000||Anisansel v. AB Volvo||Kings Co.||May 15|
|$19,850,000||McMillan v. City of New York||Kings Co.||May 15|
|$19,000,000||Zhou v. Tuxedo Ridge, LLC.||Queens Co.||Aug 21|
|$18,200,000||Zielinska v. Lutheran Medical Center||Kings Co.||Jul 19|